In the Kitchen, Non-Toxic Living

The Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheets [2022]

Who would have thought baking sheets could be toxic? I mean it’s really no surprise because it seems like everywhere we turn, there are additives, harmful chemicals, and toxic solutions that fill the shelves!  But, when you find out that these harmful chemicals might be present in your baking sheets, the reality of what we put into our bodies truly hits home.

When looking for a non-toxic baking sheet, it can be hard to trust that all companies are selling a safe product because there isn’t much regulation on this kind of thing.

That’s why we did the research and found the best non-toxic baking sheets available on the market today!

If you stick around until the end of the article, you can learn a little bit more about what you should look for when you’re buying non-toxic baking sheets, the problem with non-stick products, and the toxic chemicals that you should look to avoid when searching for a baking sheet.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I could be compensated if you decide to make a purchase. You can read my full disclosure here.

The Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheets 

TeamFar Baking Sheet

We use this baking sheet almost every day of the week. It’s pretty big compared to others (which I love for my big family), but the brand does offer a two-piece set with a smaller size if you’re cooking for fewer people.

We love that TeamFar’s baking sheets are made from stainless steel without any kind of toxic coating, so you can rest assured knowing that there won’t be any toxic substances seeping into your food (even at high temperatures), and you can buy a set of three if you’re really big into baking.

Since it’s an inch deep, it holds quite a bit of food and keeps juices and oils from spilling out. You can even put a roasting rack over it and just use it to catch the liquids!

Since it’s made of stainless steel, it’s rust-resistant and very durable, which means it can withstand years of use without major damage.

It’s also very smooth, which prevents food from sticking to the surface, and you can spray a bit of oil on it to avoid any additional sticking. (Read on to learn more about why you should avoid baking sheets that are marketed as “non-stick”.)

It is dishwasher-safe though, so cleanup couldn’t be easier. That being said, it may be a bit too big for your dishwasher (it’s too big for mine!).

The only downside to these baking sheets is that they don’t have handles, which can make moving them tricky. You can use oven mitts as handles, which is what we do. Just be careful not to dip your mitt into the oils!

After about a year of use, ours have started warping slightly at extremely high temperatures (above 450-degrees Fahrenheit), but it hasn’t been enough to alter the food in any way. My cookies don’t slide around, juices don’t spill out, and everything still seems to cook evenly.

I’m also unsure of where these baking sheets are manufactured, but I’ve reached out to TeamFar, and I’ll update this post with their answer!

Wildone Baking Sheet with Silicone Mat Set

Silicone baking mats are becoming more and more popular, and after using them you will understand why!

This set from Wildone includes 2 stainless steel baking sheets and 2 silicone baking mats. The silicone baking mats are a great alternative to non-stick baking sheets, which have been linked to hormone imbalances and weakened immune systems, and they can be used thousands of times.

The multi-use function makes them an inexpensive addition to your kitchen that’s safer and more sustainable than aluminum foil or parchment paper.

The silicone baking mats are made of 100% food-grade silicone and reinforced fiberglass, so they’re safe to use at temperatures up to 450 °F (and down to -40 °F too), which means that you can put them straight into the oven or freezer.

And you don’t need to add any cooking spray, grease, or oil to keep food from sticking.

The baking sheets are also stainless steel, which means no toxic chemicals will be leaching into your food when it comes in contact with the cooking surface.

The set is dishwasher safe for easier cleanup, and the silicone mats can be machine-washed as well.

We love that this set includes three different sizes too, so you can choose the best size pan based on what you’re cooking.

multiple pieces of Caraway bakeware on counter with cooked muffins in caraway muffin pan

Caraway Ceramic Baking Sheets

Ceramic bakeware is becoming more and more popular due to its non-stick properties, and these baking sheets from Caraway are my favorite option.

As I mentioned above, I don’t generally recommend using any kind of cookware or bakeware that’s marketed as “non-stick,” but if you’re an avid baker and really feel like you need the non-stick surface, these are a much better option than what you’ll find elsewhere.

You don’t have to use as much oil when cooking (or maybe none at all), and since they don’t contain PTFE, PFOA, lead, or cadmium, you don’t have to worry about harmful chemicals seeping into your food (even at high temperatures).

Ceramic is very durable and tends to not warp over time like some other materials (like the stainless steel baking sheets we’ve mentioned here), and we love that Caraway’s packaging is completely plastic-free!

Caraway’s non-toxic baking sheets are oven-safe up to 550 °F, so if you want to use them for high heat cooking, they’re a terrific choice. Depending on the dish you’re baking, your most optimum temperature probably lies somewhere in between 325 and 450 °F though.

Unlike the stainless steel baking sheets that we’ve recommended in this post though, Caraway recommends that you hand-wash their products (instead of using the dishwasher) in order to extend the life of the non-stick ceramic coating.

Eventually, the non-stick properties will fade away with use, but if you care for these baking sheets properly, they’re designed to last for many years.

And if food does end up sticking, you can do a deep-clean with baking soda and vinegar before washing with mild non-toxic dish soap.

P.S. If you’re an avid baker, Caraway is offering $150 off their 11-piece complete bakeware set right now. It includes everything you need to replace all of your bakeware, including a handy organizer for it all.

Gotham Steel Ultra Durable Bakeware with Quick Release Ceramic Coating

This is actually a full baking set versus one baking sheet, but Gotham’s bakeware set is free of PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS.

The ceramic coating on these non-stick baking sheets provides superior durability and is designed to last for many years.

Gotham’s 5-piece baking set includes a 12″ by 17.7″ baking sheet in addition to a 9.5″ round cake pan, a 9.5″ square pan, a 9″ by 4″ loaf pan, and a 12-cup muffin pan. (But you can buy the baking sheet on its own if you prefer.)

All of the Gotham Steel bakeware pieces are oven safe up to 500 °F and are fully dishwasher safe too.

The non-stick ceramic coating works at all temperatures, so even if you need to pop your dishes in the freezer, you’ll be safe.

If you’re trying to avoid aluminum entirely though, these probably aren’t the right choice for you because they’re made of aluminum with a ceramic coating. That being said, the coating is very durable, and these pans are super affordable too!

Unicook Baking Stone 

Stoneware isn’t just for making pizzas!

This baking stone from Unicook is a great non-toxic option for baking everything from cookies to flatbreads, and you can even use it on the grill!

We prefer stoneware like this that isn’t coated in any chemicals, so you don’t have to worry about leeching.

The stone will retain heat better than metal pans will, which means your food will cook more thoroughly and evenly.

The downside is that it’s completely flat, so it won’t hold oils or juices if you’re baking meet or vegetables, and since it doesn’t have handles, it’s a little more difficult to handle (it’s stone, so it’s pretty heavy!).

One major plus though is that the stone doesn’t have any grooves, so it’s super easy to clean (even though you can’t put it in the dishwasher).

For crispy creations preheat your stoneware first, then place your food on it before baking.

Pyrex Glass Bakeware 

While this non-toxic baking dish isn’t actually a sheet, we do love it because of the handles!

Pyrex’s glass baking dishes are oven safe up to 450°F, and they work for lots of recipes, both sweet and savory.

And since the edges are super deep, it makes for a great choice for lasagna or casseroles; just make sure to adjust your cooking times since it’ll heat so much faster than metal.

The glass is non-toxic and won’t leech anything into your food, but the glass isn’t designed to handle sudden changes in temperature (so don’t pour cold liquids into a hot dish or vice versa).

You can put it right into a preheated oven, and you can use metal utensils on it without worrying about scraping any of the coating off (because it’s not coated).

It also comes with a lid for storing or carrying to a potluck. Although the lid is plastic (which is not exactly our favorite material), so you don’t have to use it.

Why You Should Use Non-Toxic Baking Sheets

Some baking sheets and other cookware can actually be quite harmful to our health, even if we’re cooking otherwise healthy food on them.

Lead and cadmium are both somewhat common in cooking products, including baking sheets, and some baking sheets are coated with chemicals to make them more convenient for use.

These chemicals can leech into our food as we cook though—with potentially severe health consequences, so it’s best to use non-toxic bakeware when possible.

What Makes A Baking Sheet Non-Toxic?

The materials and coating used to make a baking sheet are what determines if it’s non-toxic or not.

Most bakeware is primarily made of some sort of metal, like steel or aluminum, and while the metal itself isn’t inherently toxic—but because you can scratch off the coating when using metal utensils, it can be.

Many other cookware products are coated with chemicals to make them non-stick, so even though they’re made of non-toxic, food-safe metal, the chemical coating is what makes them potentially toxic.

Some companies do offer fully non-toxic baking sheets that are made of glass or ceramic without any coating to enhance their performance.

So it’s best to do your research and find out exactly what material a baking sheet is made of before making a purchase.

What Types of Baking Sheets Should You Avoid?

If you’re in the market for a new baking sheet, there are some types that you should avoid.

We generally avoid anything that’s marketed as “non-stick” (more on that below), but if your baking sheet is non-stick (and you’re not planning to get a new one), don’t use metal utensils on it. This may scratch off some of the coatings and allow chemicals to leech into your food.

So if you’re baking something in the oven at 450°F, it’s best to use a non-stick baking sheet with wooden or silicone utensils.

Some people may also want to avoid aluminum baking sheets since aluminum has been linked to various health problems.

Are Non-Stick Baking Sheets Safe?

We do not recommend the use of non-stick baking sheets or other non-stick cookware, and there’s a lot of debate around whether non-stick baking sheets and the coatings they use are safe.

Non-stick coatings like PFOA and Teflon can leech into your food as you cook at high temperatures. And since the coating is not part of the metal, it can scratch off when you’re using your cookware and bakeware (especially if you use metal utensils) and little flakes can end up directly in your food.

Exposure to PFOA has been linked to cancer, thyroid disorders, low birth weights, kidney disease, and other health conditions. And they’ve been found in the blood of nearly every human being on earth.

In 2006, the United States EPA formed the PFOA Stewardship Program and asked companies to begin phasing out their usage of PFOA in certain products. By 2015, all of these companies reported that they stopped using PFOA in their materials.

Even newer non-stick bakeware may be cause for concern though. As mentioned in a 2017 study, “Due to toxicity concerns, PFOA has been replaced with other chemicals such as GenX, but these new alternatives are also suspected to have similar toxicity.”

And the EU is working to ban PFAS chemicals entirely.

So even though non-stick bakeware is technically “food-safe,” we’d recommend steering clear of non-stick baking sheets and sticking with stainless steel, glass, or ceramic, with a healthy amount of caution.

If you do choose to use non-stick baking sheets, be sure not to overheat them (since you shouldn’t heat non-stick cookware past 500°F).

You can read more about non-stick cookware and our decision to switch to stainless steel and cast iron here.

Have questions about enamel cookware? Find out if it’s a safe option.

Are Aluminum Baking Sheets Safe?

This is a little more complicated than a yes or no answer, but aluminum baking sheets are generally safe to use.

It’s best to use silicone-covered utensils like tongs when flipping or stirring (in order to avoid scratching the aluminum). And you shouldn’t use abrasive brushes when cleaning as that could lead to scratches as well. 

As long as you don’t scratch your aluminum baking sheet, which can release aluminum from the sheet and into your food, it’s safe to use.

If you research aluminum a little further, you’ll find that aluminum can leach into food in small amounts, especially if the food is acidic (like tomato sauce or citruses). And aluminum ingestion has been associated with various health risks.

The small amount of aluminum that passes into the food, however, is likely not an issue for healthy adults, but it can pose a higher risk to people with a history of renal failure or to smaller children.

So we recommend sticking with stainless steel, cast iron, and ceramic bakeware if you have a choice. And using aluminum baking sheets can be fine so long as you take precautions when cleaning them, putting them in the oven, or even storing them for later use.

stack of baking dishes

Are Baking Sheet Liners Toxic?

Some people use baking sheet liners to decrease their clean up time or reduce their calorie intake, but it’s best not to.

Aluminum foil is probably the most commonly used liner, and there has been research to suggest that high usage of aluminum foil can lead to adverse health effects because it leaches into our food when heated.

Parchment paper is another popular liner, especially when making cookies and other sweet treats. Unfortunately, parchment paper’s non-stick properties are sometimes due to the use of PFAS (like Teflon), and bleached parchment paper may leach dioxins when heated.

(We talk more about dioxins in our article about non-toxic diapers.)

If you need to use parchment paper, however, we recommend this unbleached parchment paper from If You Care, which was independently tested and found to not contain PFAS.

Types of Non-Toxic Baking Sheets

As you can see in our product recommendations, there are a number of non-toxic baking sheets you should get your hands on. But how do you know which baking sheet to choose if you’re in a store and buying directly off of the shelf?

The material your baking sheet is made of can make a big difference in its non-toxicity. Here are the types of non-toxic baking sheets we recommend:

Stainless Steel Baking Sheets

Stainless steel is a great material for non-toxic baking sheets because it heats evenly and lasts for a long time, and it’s usually quite affordable too.

Stainless steel baking sheets are also fairly easy to clean as long as you use a lubricant like cooking spray or oil on them.

You’ll often see stainless steel baking sheets and other cooking products marked with numbers like “304,” “18/8,” etc. These numbers refer to the “grade” of the stainless steel and the amount of chromium and nickel in it.

Nickel is often added into stainless steel to keep it from rusting, so if you use stainless steel bakeware, make sure you don’t let super salty or acidic foods sit for long periods of time. If you do, it may release nickel into your food. Or you can purchase nickel-free stainless steel.

The baking sheets that we’ve recommended above are all made with high-quality 430 18/0 stainless steel without a chemical coating. This means they are stainless 18% chromium and contain less than 1% nickel (hence the 18/0).

Ceramic Baking Sheets

Another non-toxic baking sheet option is ceramic. Ceramic baking sheets are usually strong, durable, stain-resistant, and easy to clean.

If you’re determined to use some sort of non-stick bakeware, ceramic is the way to go (and we really like the ones from Caraway).

Ceramic can usually tolerate high heats, which means you’ll be able to bake at higher temperatures with them than many other types of baking sheets, and ceramic is also chemically inert, so it’s great for cooking acidic foods.

That being said, some companies aren’t entirely open about the ingredients used in their non-stick coating, so we still advise you to use caution when cooking with ceramic, and you should always check the manufacturer’s website for specific care instructions to follow when using ceramic non-stick baking sheets.

Stoneware Baking Sheets

Stoneware has amazing heat retention properties and is great for keeping food warm during meals and for getting foods crispy in the oven. It also draws moisture away from food and doesn’t retain any odors.

If you’re looking for stoneware bakeware, you’ll come across two main types: unglazed and glazed. Unglazed stoneware is porous and can absorb moisture, so it’s usually coated in a non-stick material to prevent sticking and make cleanup easier.

We recommend opting for unglazed stoneware when you can find it.

It’s a great choice for bakeware. Just remember you can’t use soap or detergent on them which is the main drawback.

Glass Bakeware

Glass is another option for non-toxic baking. Glass baking sheets are easy to use, they won’t warp in the dishwasher, and they’re usually clear, which makes it easier to check your food for doneness and monitor its progress during cooking.

That being said, glass cooks a bit faster than metal, so you’ll have to adjust your cooking times if you choose to use glass bakeware.

Glass bakeware is also easy to clean. You can simply handwash them in soapy water or most can be put in the dishwasher.

As noted above, we love using Pyrex baking dishes — you just have to be careful you don’t break them! Most glass baking sheets are tempered, which means they’re super strong and intended to withstand very high oven temperatures. And they’re freezer-safe too (but you shouldn’t take them directly from the freezer to the oven, or vice versa.

You don’t have to worry about scraping any coatings off of it either or having it smell. Just spray it with oil or cooking spray before use and you’re good to go. 

Silicone Baking Mats

Silicone is another option for non-toxic baking. The surface of silicone baking mats is made from silica and can be used for a lot of different dishes. Silicone mats are easy to clean and some are dishwasher-safe too!

Silicone is a popular choice for non-toxic baking sheets because it can handle high temperatures and is non-stick.

However, there are some cons to using silicone baking mats that you should know about. Silicone can melt if exposed to very high temperatures for a long period of time. So if you’re wanting something that will be safe to use in the broiler, we don’t recommend going with silicone.

You can also find these in muffin tins, loaf pans, and cupcake holders! Learn more about cooking with silicone products!

How to Choose the Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheets for Your Family

Now that you have a good idea of what types of non-toxic baking sheets are on the market, it’s time to choose the best one for your family.

One of the first things you’ll want to think about is your budget. Non-toxic baking sheets tend to be on the more expensive side, so if price is an issue for you, make sure you take that into consideration.

You may also want to consider what types of dishes or foods you’ll be using your non-toxic baking sheets for. Glass is best for acidic foods, meats, and casseroles, and stainless steel tends to be good for baking breads, cookies, and other baked goods.

If you want the best of both worlds — non-stick, but not coated in chemicals or toxins — silicone or ceramic is a great option.

Overall, there isn’t a “best of the best” non-toxic baking sheet that we can recommend to everyone. You’ll have to find the one that’s best for your kitchen and what you want to use it for!

Since we’re talking kitchen products, you may be interested in our list of the best non-toxic food storage containers too. There are tons of great options, especially for storing leftovers and carrying your lunch! 

You may also like...